Want to Know?
Search AINews
   
 

Front Page
Adult Film News
Adult Media News
Business News
Club & Appearance News
Freedom & the Law
Internet News
Lifestyles Arts Health Charity
Letters to the Editor
Columns
Movie Reviews
InnerViews
Star Pages
Advertise With AINews

Pamela Peaks in the Kitchen?! and Pamela Peaks Speaks Shows here!

Jessica Difeo at Twistys

More
Stories From

Freedom & the Law

Noname Jane Settles With Violet Blue

Jim Powers Shoot Robbed

Vicky Vette Not Behind Campaign Prank

In Defense of Kayden Kross

WAE Reps ASACP

ASACP at Atlanta Forum

Organizers Help ASACP at Exxxotica

ASACP/Stormy Daniels DC Video

Rodnievision Joins ASACP

ASACP at Storerotica

Tera Patrick, Evan Seinfeld in RTA PSA

WantedList Sues Ohanessian

ASACP Day in San Diego

Eurowebtainment Represents ASACP at International Event

Porn.com ASACP Corporate Sponsor

Congresswoman Honors Joan Irvine, ASACP

David Lord's Official Statement

Stormy Daniels, Joy King Speak Out

Sunny Leone for Youth Voter Registration

ASACP Named Overall Winner

Stormy, ASACP go to Washington

Vivid Halts Utah Group

Sandy Bunz Arrested

Ducati Sues Venetian Hotel

Theresa Flynt Joins ASACP AC

Vivid Sues PornoTube

Love Shack Celebrates Anniversary

ASACP Participates in Coalition

Bogus Booking Boy Back!

Ducati Awarded Trademarks

Nick Manning Faces Eviction

Fred Salaff Out of Panama

Look What's Obscene in Kansas

DOJ Gets Word From the Trenches

ASACP Strikes Gold with Dating Gold

ACLU Comments on Victory

Victory for Free Speech in Nevada

ASACP, Adult Industry Launch RTA

Fred Salaff Free at Last

Vivid, Kardashian Reach Settlement

Fred Salaff Gives - Will You?

New Milestone for ASACP Hotline

Urgent Website Labeling News

Ohio Senate Approves Bill To Limit Strip Clubs

Fred Salaff Trial Set in Stone

Porn Queen Wants To Excite Milan Voters

HUSTLER - a Name you Can Trust
October 30, 2001 02:15pm
Supreme Court Discusses Porn Depicting Minors
Source: Reuters
by: James Vicini

(WASHINGTON, DC) -- The U.S. Supreme Court [http://www.SupremeCourtUS.gov] questioned on Tuesday whether a law aimed at computer-generated pictures that "convey the impression of child pornography" may be applied to popular, award-winning movies such as "Traffic," "Lolita," "Romeo and Juliet" and "Titanic."

The justices grappled with a 1996 federal law covering computer-generated images that do not involve real children and whether it may be applied to very young adult actors and actresses who look like minors in a movie.

Justice Stephen Breyer cited "Traffic" [http://TrafficTheMovie.com] with the scene of the high school daughter of the nation's drug czar appearing to have sex with a drug dealer; "Lolita," a film about a middle-aged man's obsession with a young girl; and "Titanic" [http://TitanicMovie.com], depicting a love affair by a young couple on a doomed ship.

He said each film showed simulated sexual activity by a minor. "Why am I not guilty under your interpretation of a federal crime?" Breyer asked lawyer for government Deputy Solicitor General Paul Clement.

Justice Antonin Scalia quickly interrupted, trying to assist Clement, saying the law defined specific sexual conduct, such as intercourse, masturbation, bestiality and showing of the genitals.

No Crime to Rent "Traffic"

"We're not prosecuting people who pick up 'Traffic' at the Blockbuster," Clement said, referring to the video rental chain.

The 1996 law covered any visual depiction "that appears to be a minor engaging in sexually explicit conduct." The law contained a provision prohibiting any visual depiction "that conveys the impression" of a minor engaging in such conduct.

The so-called "virtual" child pornography law makes it a crime to have computer-generated pictures of what appears to be minors engaging in sexual acts, even if the images do not involve real children.

Justice Sandra Day O'Connor said the Supreme Court previous rulings have held that the pornography actually harmed the child. "What is your primary reliance when you don't have that?" she asked Clement.

Justice John Paul Stevens asked whether Clement, an appointee of President Bush, felt the law would prohibit an 18-year-old from playing certain movie roles.

Clement replied that movie studios could simply not include scenes of sexually explicit conduct or could use a "body double" - another actress or actor to play the scene.

H. Louis Sirkin, representing a trade association of businesses involved in selling "adult-oriented materials" [http://FreeSpeechCoalition.com] argued the law should be struck down as a form of censorship that violates constitutional free-speech rights.

He said the law was too broad to pass constitutional muster. "It's a blanket, across-the-board prohibition," Sirkin said, adding that the law failed to make an exception for medical or scientific material.

As soon as Sirkin began his arguments, Scalia said: "I am trying to think of what great works of art would be taken away from us if we were unable to show minors copulating."

Stevens cited as a possible example the movie of the Shakespeare play about young lovers, "Romeo and Juliet."

Scalia responded: "You've seen a different version of that than I have."

The Supreme Court is expected to issue it's ruling early next year.

Chief Justice William Rehnquist opened the session by announcing the court would hear arguments at the U.S. courthouse on Wednesday for the third day in a row after anthrax was discovered in the court's basement mailroom.

Pamela Peaks Speaks TV Shows

Related Sites - WARNING! May lead to graphic content

AINews Movie Spotlight The Movies That
Make The Story
Eighteen And Confused #2
Eighteen And Confused #2
Buy Now!

 
Jewel De'nyle Babes In Pornland - Teen Babes
Jewel De'nyle Babes In Pornland - Teen Babes
Buy Now!

 

Catalina Cruz

Top Stories

A Call for Help

Raffi Vartanian Moderates

WAW Reps ASACP

Penthouse Films Wrap Party

Genesis Features Porn Star Presidents

Shay Lynn Thankful in November

Moxxie Maddron Screws Fans

Diamonds of Depravity: Autumn Approaching

UGO Features Casey Parker

Hustler Casting Call

A Day to End Violence

Charity Toy Drive

Osa Lovely, Ravyn X on Last Call

Oxford Store Host Pole Demo

Delotta Brown Launches Site