Want to Know?
Search AINews
   
 

Front Page
Adult Film News
Adult Media News
Business News
Club & Appearance News
Freedom & the Law
Internet News
Lifestyles Arts Health Charity
Letters to the Editor
Columns
Movie Reviews
InnerViews
Star Pages
Contact Staff
Advertise With AINews

Pamela Peaks in the Kitchen?! and Pamela Peaks Speaks Shows here!

Club Jessica Jaymes - Official Website

More
Stories From

Freedom & the Law

Final USC 18 2257 Regs

ASACP at FCACP Meeting

FSC Introduces New Lobbyist

Benefits of Supporting ASACP

FSC Releases Code of Ethics

Voting Begins in FSC Board Election

FSC Summit Bridges Adult & Mainstream

Noname Jane Settles With Violet Blue

Jim Powers Shoot Robbed

Vicky Vette Not Behind Campaign Prank

In Defense of Kayden Kross

WAE Reps ASACP

ASACP at Atlanta Forum

Organizers Help ASACP at Exxxotica

ASACP/Stormy Daniels DC Video

Rodnievision Joins ASACP

ASACP at Storerotica

Tera Patrick, Evan Seinfeld in RTA PSA

WantedList Sues Ohanessian

ASACP Day in San Diego

Eurowebtainment Represents ASACP at International Event

Porn.com ASACP Corporate Sponsor

Congresswoman Honors Joan Irvine, ASACP

David Lord's Official Statement

Stormy Daniels, Joy King Speak Out

Sunny Leone for Youth Voter Registration

ASACP Named Overall Winner

Stormy, ASACP go to Washington

Vivid Halts Utah Group

Sandy Bunz Arrested

Ducati Sues Venetian Hotel

Theresa Flynt Joins ASACP AC

Vivid Sues PornoTube

Love Shack Celebrates Anniversary

ASACP Participates in Coalition

Bogus Booking Boy Back!

Ducati Awarded Trademarks

Nick Manning Faces Eviction

Fred Salaff Out of Panama

Look What's Obscene in Kansas

DOJ Gets Word From the Trenches

ASACP Strikes Gold with Dating Gold

ACLU Comments on Victory

Victory for Free Speech in Nevada

ASACP, Adult Industry Launch RTA

Fred Salaff Free at Last

Vivid, Kardashian Reach Settlement

Fred Salaff Gives - Will You?

New Milestone for ASACP Hotline

Urgent Website Labeling News

Ohio Senate Approves Bill To Limit Strip Clubs

Fred Salaff Trial Set in Stone

Porn Queen Wants To Excite Milan Voters

HUSTLER - a Name you Can Trust
March 05, 2001 02:13pm
Court To Decide Same-Site Case
Source: AP
by: Anne Gearan

(WASHINGTON) -- The Supreme Court said Monday it will decide whether cities can prohibit more than one adult business from operating on the same site. In the same sitting, the court turned away other free-speech cases.

Two Los Angeles adult bookstore operators, already restricted from operating too close to similar businesses, said it is unfair to bar them also from diversifying an existing business.

Free speech defenders also say piling zoning restrictions onto adult businesses amounts to nothing more than trying to shut them down.

These other free speech cases were up Monday:

-The justices turned away appeals dealing with the Ku Klux Klan's participation in a highway cleanup campaign and a student barred from giving a valedictory address that talked about Jesus.

-The court also ruled unanimously that Indian tribes do not qualify for exemptions on releases of documents under the Freedom of Information Act.

In the Klan case, Missouri lost a bid to ban the organization from its Adopt-A-Highway cleanup program. The court, without comment, turned down the state's argument that it should be allowed to bar the Klan from the litter control program because the organization won't accept blacks and other minorities as members.

``It's what I expected right from the beginning,'' said Thomas Robb, national director of the Ku Klux Klan in Harrison, Ark. ``With us it was purely a constitutional issue.''

Missouri's lawyers had said the state has a right to control its own speech and that allowing the Klan to participate would violate the 1964 Civil Rights Act's ban on racial discrimination in federally funded programs.

Also without comment, the court turned down an appeal from a California high school valedictorian barred from giving a graduation speech in which he had planned to ask the audience to ``accept God's love'' and to live by ``Jesus' example.''

The bookstore case builds on the court's previous rulings that local governments may pass restrictive zoning laws intended to prevent the development of red light districts.

In Los Angeles, adult-oriented businesses such as X-rated movie houses, sex toy shops and adult bookstores may not operate within 1,000 feet of one another, nor within 500 feet of a church, school, park or residential neighborhood.

In passing those 1978 rules, the city cited a study charting harmful effects of concentrations of adult businesses, including higher crime and lower property values.

In 1983, the city refined its rules to prohibit multiple adult businesses from operating in the same building.

``This issue is, did we want the adult entertainment mall?'' said Claudia McGee Henry, senior assistant city attorney in Los Angeles. ``It was never the city's intent to disperse adult businesses, but then allow a mall with as many businesses as you can cram in there.''

Two adult bookstores with separate video viewing stations later challenged the 1983 rule as an unconstitutional limit on free expression. The 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals (news - web sites) eventually ruled that the city did not provide enough evidence of the potential harm from having multiple businesses on a single site.

Los Angeles has a ``substantial government interest'' in reducing crime in its neighborhoods, but it did not provide enough evidence that the restriction would serve that goal, the appeals court said.

The city's lawyers said a 1984 Supreme Court ruling ``does not require a city council to independently investigate or corroborate each potential problem when it acts in furtherance of the public interest.''

The bookstores' lawyers said a zoning law like the Los Angeles ordinance ``would allow the absolute destruction of any adult bookstore business'' by defining each type of product as a separate business that could not occur in the same store.

A Supreme Court decision in the case is expected to clarify what justification a local government needs for the multiple-business ban - or whether such a rule cannot be justified.

``I think we are seeing cities and counties around the country continuously stretching the rationale for imposing zoning restrictions on adult businesses, and this case is about as much of a stretch as you can have,'' said Steven Shapiro, legal director for the American Civil Liberties Union (news - web sites), which has fought restrictions on adult bookstores in the past.

Using a broad definition of speech - here titillating or pornographic books and videos - the ACLU says that Los Angeles wrongly seeks zoning rules that treat sexual speech differently from other kinds of speech.

``At some point this becomes thinly veiled subterfuge'' to put adult bookstores out of business, Shapiro said.

The cases are Los Angeles v. Alameda Books, 00-799; Yarnell v. Cuffley, 00-289; Niemeyer v. Oroville Union High School District, 00-1074; and U.S. Department of Interior v. Klamath Water Users Protective Association, 99-1871.

Pamela Peaks in the Kitchen?! TV Shows

Kayden Kross at Twistys

Top Stories

Bridgette B at Downtown Rhino

Internext Party Schedule

Tera Patrick Parties

Trina Michaels' Christmas in Tijuana

Pink Visual Highlights Mobile at AEE

Do It Like a Pornstar

Vivid AVN Kick-Off Party

Silk, Wylder, Angel at FSC Booth

Minka Returns to Score

MWA: Kayden Kross, Roxy Jezel, Lisa Ann, Daisy Duxe

Sunny Lane at AEE

Hustler Magazine All-Sex Issue

MWA: Roxy Jezel, Lisa Ann, Gianna Lynn

Hustler's 2009 AEE Girls

Not Three's Company XXX

Debi's Diamonds of Depravity: Las Vegas Bound

3 Virgins at PAW Booth

AEE Stages 1st Live Performance

Tribe AfterParty

A&E Fan Seminars