Quick Index
 Adult Industry News
Search AINews Database
Type Keyword or Phrase Here
2018 Gentlemen’s Club EXPO and Adult Nightclub & Exotic Dancer Awards Show Pornography feminists unshackle their desires and celebrate their sexuality in the patriarchal world
   
 

Front Page
Film News
Media News
Business News
Clubs & Appearances
Law & Politics
Internet & Mobile News
Lifestyles Arts Health Charity
Letters to the Editor
Columns
Movie Spotlight Reviews
Interviews
Pornstar Pages
AINews Staff
Ad Rates
PR 101: Press Release Service

Porn for GEEKS! Meet me & my friends!

PumaSwede.com

April 27, 2005 04:00am
Virtual Prostitutes: Extending the Protections of Virtual Child Pornography to Cyberprostitutes
Source: Adult Industry News
by: Jessica R. Blaemire

Her skin is taut. The lines of her body gently become exposed as she removes each article of clothing. He sits on the bed, anxiously awaiting this act that he has paid for with last week's salary. He takes her. The sex is rushed, slightly awkward, and very human. On the screen she is prostitute, and he is her very eager customer. However, the images, seemingly real, are virtual, and exist only in cyberspace.

One unique way the internet has transformed sexual experiences is with the advent of "virtual" people. These people look, sound and move like real human beings. These "people," though, are digitally created and could possibly have no real human counterparts. If a virtual prostitute lures a customer in cyberspace, directed by text, is it prostitution? It is doubtful, under our current laws, that any crime has been committed.

No cases have been brought regarding virtual prostitutes, and it is something that is rarely discussed. The existence of virtual children, however, is a very hot issue and has been widely argued and publicized. Internet technologies allow depictions of children to be extremely realistic, and often indistinguishable from the real thing. A recent episode of Law and Order: Special Victims Unit highlighted this issue, and described how girls who are legal adults can be altered to appear much younger. Although objectionable to many, the right to produce these "young" sex objects has been protected by the Supreme Court.

The United States Supreme Court ruled in Ashcroft v. Free Speech Coalition that there is nothing illegal about using virtual children to create cyberporn. The Supreme Court determined that porn which does not depict actual children must be protected under the Constitution. A statute cannot prohibit virtual child pornography, as no children are being harmed.

In its ruling, the Supreme Court overturned the lower court's ruling which held that virtual child porn should be illegal because it seemed to be real children, and could encourage child molesters. The Supreme Court rejected this reasoning noting, "The mere tendency of speech to encourage unlawful acts is not a sufficient reason for banning it" (see Ashcroft v. Free Speech Coalition). Subsequent courts have followed the Supreme Court's decision and overturned convictions of virtual child pornographers.

Following this reasoning, it is unlikely that virtual prostitutes and their customers will run into any legal troubles. Prostitution statutes will not apply as there are no real prostitutes (and sometimes, no real human customers) involved. Even if the images are "based" on real people and have real people at the controls, it is unlikely that any prostitution charges will emerge. There is a concern that virtual prostitution encourages real prostitution. However, this is also not enough to make virtual prostitution illegal. As the Supreme Court noted, even though the virtual acts might encourage the real thing, this is not enough justification to override people's First Amendment rights. If the Supreme Court was willing to use this reasoning to protect what is arguably a much more objectionable form of expression (virtual child porn), they will very likely use this reasoning to protect virtual prostitutes and their customers.

-Jessica R. Blaemire

Ms. Blaemire is a law student at the University of Virginia. With her article, she is not attempting to give legal advice. For a copy of her entire research project, "A New Face on an Old Profession: A Look at Prostitution on the Internet," please contact her at JRB6n@Virginia.edu.

2018 Gentlemen’s Club EXPO and Adult Nightclub & Exotic Dancer Awards Show

Related Stories

Related Sites - WARNING! Graphic Content

RavenBay01.3gp

2018 Gentlemen’s Club EXPO and Adult Nightclub & Exotic Dancer Awards Show

Top Stories

Stokely Cherry OTM

August Taylor MILF PoY Nom

Phoenix Divina Hooking

ED Expo Opening Party

Vickie Jay on VNALive

HardArt 3 Pic Deal

Iron Girls 6

Carmen Valentina NightMoves Nom

Dillion Harper at Expose

Texas, Monroe, Valentien to SEXPO

The Puppeteer

Urban X Voting Open

Brooklyn Chase in Madison

HardArt's Hypersexuals a Success!

TES Affiliate Conference

Jessica Johnson Hooking

MWA: 07/27/18

Vote Olive Glass, NightMoves

Attn: Club Owners, Managers, Staff, Entertainers

2018 Inked Awards

Hard Art's Hypersexual

MWA: 07/25/18

Johnson Hosts Urban X

Dee Wallace at Horrorfest

MWA: 07/19/18 - XRCO

AirBnB Discriminates Against Sara Jay

Hard Art Shoots First

MWA: 07/21/18

Holly Hendrix at Exxxotica

Karen Fisher at Exxxotica

Carmen Valentina at Exxxotica

DomCon Registration Opens

Luna Star at Exxxotica

Elvira Receives Price Award

BSF Media Welcomes Sabrina Deep

MWA: 07/18/18

Jenevieve Hexxx Site Launch

Sex Expo NY 2018

MWA: 07/16/18

MWA: 07/15/18

Bush 7

Hard Art Signs Director

Pulse Inks Hard Art

MWA: 06/28/18

New Studio: Hard Art

XRCO Changes Venue

The Roast of April O'Neil

McCullough, Rai on Inside

Morgan, Foxxx CoHo XRCO

Big Ass Rubdown ~ Reviewer Rated

MWA: 05/03/18

MWA: 04/29/18

MWA: 04/28/18

Natasha Nice Free Agent

Holly Hendrix Self Booking

CDC: Undetectable HIV

2018 XRCO Nominees

YummyGirl

Natasha Nice Gangbang

Amateur Introductions 26

Sex Expo NY 2018

2018 XRCO Awards Announced

Anal Violation of Bonnie Grey ~ Reviewer Rated

Eros, a Short Film

Lee Signs Victoria June

Maxine X Voted #1

Czernich Releases Heavy Rubber 37

Legal Panel: Weinstein, #MeToo

Consent Checklist

Nice Girls Swallow 10

Paradise Wins Best Condom

Paradise, Astroglide StorErotica Nom

Paradise Marketing New Website

Dennis Paradise Inducted

More
Stories From

Columns

MWA: 07/27/18

MWA: 07/25/18

MWA: 07/19/18 - XRCO

MWA: 07/21/18

MWA: 07/18/18

MWA: 07/16/18

MWA: 07/15/18

MWA: 06/28/18

MWA: 05/03/18

MWA: 04/29/18

MWA: 04/28/18

MWA: 03/04/18

MWA: 02/28/18

MWA: 02/22/18

MWA: 02/18/2018

MWA: 01/16/18

MWA: 12/26/17

MWA: 12/21/17

MWA: 12/16/17

MWA: 12/10/17

MWA: 12/09/17

MWA: 12/06/17

MWA: 12/05/17

Gonzo with Eddie Powell

MWA: 11/07/17

MWA: 10/06/17

MWA: 08/27/17

MWA: 08/26/17

MWA: 07/27/17

MWA: 07/24/17

MWA: 07/01/17

MWA: 06/21/17

Dr. Chauntelle Tibbals Interview

MWA: 06/20/17

MWA: 06/05/17

Getting Into Porn

MWA: 05/27/17

MWA: 05/14/17

MWA: 04/12/17

MWA: 04/11/17

MWA: 03/25/17

MWA: 03/23/17

MWA: 03/12/17

MWA: 03/10/17

MWA: 03/06/17

MWA: 03/05/17

MWA: 03/01/17

MWA: 02/24/17

AEE 2017: A Resounding Success

MWA: 01/09/17

MWA: 01/06/17

MWA: 12/31/16

MWA: 12/20/16

MWA: 12/19/16

MWA: 12/18/16

MWA: 11/01/16

MWA: 10/30/16

MWA: 10/14/16

Are You an iDriver?

MWA: 09/14/16

MWA: 09/12/16

Columns Section Index

     
Copyright © 1998 - 2018 Adult Industry News (AINews.com)
All materials constituting text, articles, press releases, stories, columns, photographs, graphics, and code on the AINews.com domain are protected by copyright, and either owned by Adult Industry News (AINews.com), or reproduced with permission from other copyright owners. It may be downloaded and printed for personal reference, but not otherwise copied, altered in any way, or transmitted to others, without the written permission of Adult Industry News (AINews.com).