Quick Index
 Adult Industry News
Search AINews Database
Type Keyword or Phrase Here
Are you TOUGH ENOUGH for Joanna Angel? EXPO 2014, August 24-27, Mandalay Bay, Las Vegas
   
 

Front Page
Film News
Media News
Business News
Clubs & Appearances
Law & Politics
Internet & Mobile News
Lifestyles Arts Health Charity
Letters to the Editor
Columns
Movie Spotlight Reviews
Interviews
Pornstar Pages
AINews Staff
Ad Rates
PR 101: Press Release Service

Caliente Swinger Vacations!

Brea Bennett at Twistys

March 29, 2000 07:58am
Court Limits Strippers' Freedom
Source: AP
by: Laurie Asseo

(WASHINGTON) -- The Supreme Court today limited some of the freedom-of-expression protections that permit nude dancing.

The justices, by a 6-3 vote, reinstated an Erie, Pa., public-indecency ordinance that requires women who work as barroom dancers to wear at least pasties and a G-string when performing.

Pennsylvania's highest court had struck down the law, ruling that it unlawfully infringed expressive freedom, as protected by the Constitution's First Amendment.

Today's decision is sure to have broad impact. Nude entertainment is featured in some 3,000 adult clubs nationwide, the justices had been told.

They said the Pennsylvania court was wrong.

Writing in the court's main opinion, Justice Sandra Day O'Connor said nude dancing is ``expressive conduct'' that merits some First Amendment protection.

However, she added, the nude-dancing ban furthers Erie's ``interest in combating the negative secondary effects associated with adult entertainment establishments,'' such as crime.

O'Connor said the ordinance was aimed at combating crime and other negative effects of having adult entertainment establishments, and not at the erotic message of nude dancing.

Even if the ban ``has some minimal effect on the erotic message by muting that portion of the expression that occurs when the last stitch is dropped,'' O'Connor said, the dancers are free to perform wearing pasties and G-strings. Any effect on overall expression is minimal, she said.

The main part of her opinion was joined by Chief Justice William H. Rehnquist and Justices Anthony M. Kennedy and Stephen G. Breyer.

Justices Antonin Scalia and Clarence Thomas, in a separate opinion by Scalia, voted to uphold the law on different grounds, citing ``the traditional power of government to foster good morals ... and the acceptability of the traditional judgment ... that nude public dancing itself is immoral.''

However, Scalia also contended the case was moot because the nightclub at issue, known as Kandyland, had been sold.

Justice David H. Souter wrote separately that he agreed with O'Connor's analysis, but that he believed the city had not shown its ordinance was designed to deal with ``real harms.'' He said the city should be given a chance to do so.

Justices John Paul Stevens and Ruth Bader Ginsburg dissented from the ruling, saying in an opinion by Stevens that the court had decided for the first time that secondary effects ``may justify the total suppression of protected speech.''

``Indeed, the plurality opinion concludes that admittedly trivial advancements of a state's interests may provide the basis for censorship,'' Stevens wrote.

The Erie dispute was not the Supreme Court's first tour of the far reaches of free-speech law. In 1991, a badly splintered court ruled that nude dancing is a form of expression within the First Amendment's ``outer perimeters'' and is entitled to some protection from government censorship.

But that 1991 ruling also allowed Indiana to ban all barroom-style nude dancing under a state law generally prohibiting public nudity.

The Pennsylvania Supreme Court, voting 4-3 in 1998, struck down Erie's ordinance after calling the splintered 1991 decision a ``hodgepodge of opinions'' that offered little guidance.

The 1994 ordinance had been challenged by Nick Panos, who used to own the Kandyland nude-dancing club. He since has sold the club to a new owner, Joseph Cunningham, who closed it down and opened a similar club, Kandy's Dinner Theater, at a new location.

The newer club, surrounded by auto parts stores, gas stations and fast-food restaurants, is the only establishment in Erie where women performers dance while naked. A lighted sign out front proclaims: ``First Amendment Rights Headquarters.''

A key issue in the Erie case was whether city officials enacted a ``content-neutral'' law against public nudity in general, or whether they specifically targeted nude dancing.

O'Connor said the ordinance was ``on its face a content-neutral restriction that regulates conduct, not First Amendment expression.''

``The ordinance regulates conduct, and any incidental impact on the expressive element of nude dancing'' is minimal, O'Connor said. The requirement to wear G-strings and pasties ``leaves ample capacity to convey the dancer's erotic message,'' she added.

Stevens' dissent contended the ordinance was ``aimed directly at the dancers in establishments such as Kandyland'' and should be held ``patently invalid.''

One issue before the justices had been whether Panos' departure from the scene had made the dispute legally moot, but the court last June denied his attempt to have them declare just that and thereby preserve his state Supreme Court victory.

O'Connor said the case was not moot because the club could reopen and also because the court has an interest in keeping people who won a lower court ruling from seeking to ``insulate a favorable decision from review.''

The case is Erie vs. Pap's A.M., 98-1161.

Are you TOUGH ENOUGH for Joanna Angel?

Related Stories

Casey Cumz 01

See BiBi Jones at Digital Playground

Top Stories

Sheila Marie on Reality TV

Testing the Waters

Cutting Edge Changes Staff

MWA: 07/23/14

MWA: 07/22/14

MWA: 07/21/14

Tweets = Cash with PornPitch

Proud Parents ~ Reviewer Rated

RNSU July 17

Next Day Test in LV

MWA: 07/13/14

Condomless Sex

The Goddess Lives

A Legend Looks Back

Nikki Phoenix Hosts Palomino

RNSU Thurs July 10

Nikki Delano at Crazy Horse

Resurgence of the Goddess

Pornstar Graduates Law School

July 3 Rock-N-SeXXXy-Uncencored

More on Belle Knox

Morgan Del Ray Karaoke XXX

MWA: 05/21/14

The Temptation of Eve ~ Reviewer Rated

Cumisha Amado on Vivid Radio

Yoga for Lovers

She's Judas & Available

Nikki Delano on Jukeboxx

Lapdance Lingerie in Neighbors

XRCO Welcomes Rich Hansen

IIM Party June 13

Hustler EDM Maniac Party

Layla Price Stars

Julia Sands Karaoke XXX

Susana Molina in Baci Lingerie

Fetish Con Dates

Porn's Greatest Star

James Deen June Promo

Exxxotica Exhibitors Lining Up

AdultVerifiedVideoChat iPad Contest

Sunny Leone Hosts Splitsvilla

Porn Star Game Night

Camming Con Moves Dates

Discount Club Owners Expo Tickets

Teal Conrad at Sapphire NYC

Exquisite Distributes DDF

Cherie Deville Returns

Alana Evans at WonderCon

Risque Starr Sisters Parties

Natasha Voya PSK

The Sexual Liberation of Anna Lee ~ Reviewer Rated

Carter Cruise at Exxxotica

Belle Knox at Exxxotica

Rock'N'SeXXXy & Hustler

Puma Swede Opens Desire

Nikki Phoenix XRCO Nom

Maddy O'Reilly is Slutwoman

Alex Chance jGrrl

Tony Batman Conquers LA

Alexa Aimes NYC Tour

2014 AVN News Rack Part 2

Roxanne Rae Available

Minka Karaoke XXX

Rio Lee Heads Cherry Pimps

Immoral Mayhem

XRCO Sponsorship Opportunities

Rotten Hosting Vivid Radio

Cherie Deville Available

Tony Batman Crazy Appearances

Inside The Industry 03/19/2014

Chanel Preston Interview

Alicia Silver Productions Content

Adrianna Luna Dance Dates

Entertainment is Entertainment is Entertainment

More
Stories From

Clubs & Appearances

Nikki Phoenix Hosts Palomino

Nikki Delano at Crazy Horse

Morgan Del Ray Karaoke XXX

Cumisha Amado on Vivid Radio

Nikki Delano on Jukeboxx

Julia Sands Karaoke XXX

Hustler EDM Maniac Party

IIM Party June 13

MWA: 05/21/14

Discount Club Owners Expo Tickets

Teal Conrad at Sapphire NYC

Natasha Voya PSK

Alana Evans at WonderCon

Puma Swede Opens Desire

Tony Batman Conquers LA

Alexa Aimes NYC Tour

Risque Starr Sisters Parties

Carter Cruise at Exxxotica

Belle Knox at Exxxotica

Minka Karaoke XXX

Tony Batman Crazy Appearances

Adrianna Luna Dance Dates

Naomi Knight at Mansion

Bridget the Midget at Trixie's

Starr Sisters at DreamGirls

Southern Somer Karaoke XXX

Gentlemen's Club Expo

Jayden Lee at Sapphire NYC

Bonnie Rotten Live Shows

Corpsy's Birthday Party

Nikki Benz in Florida

Sam Phillips B'day Bash

Britney Shannon at Babe's

Amber Lynn at XRCO

Teagan Presley at Al's

Nikki Phoenix Walks Runway

Danger, LaCroix Host XXX Nights

Ginger Lynn at Susie's Delights

Sasha Slayer Karaoke XXX

Eliza Allure Karaoke XXX

Sapphire NYC Super Bowl Lineup

Nikki Phoenix Release Party

Savanna Samson Wine Tastings

Awards Co-Hosts Q&A

Nikki Phoenix Releases Single

Nikita Von James at AEE

HotWendyPR Clients at AEE

Nookie Chat Throws Party

Galaxy Talent AEE Signings

Holly Hanna at AVN Expo

Britney Amber at AEE

Ryder Skye Signs with Ideal Image Models

Brooklyn Chase Signs at AEE

Nikki Delano AEE Signing Schedule

Suicide Sirens Hardcore Burlesque

Kayla-Jane Danger at AEE

Jenna J Ross at AEE

AEE Play Party

Lisa Ann at Wild Cherry

Caroline Pierce Karaoke XXX

Nikki Phoenix at CES

Addie Juniper Karaoke XXX

Café Royale Takeover

Miss LA Karaoke XXX

Richelle Ryan in Albuquerque

Sara Jay at Stadium Club

Daisy Marie at Cheerleaders

Karaoke XXX Xmas Party

Eva Lovia in Baltimore

Headquarters XXXmas Party

Cali Rose at Allstar's

Chanel Preston Tours Oregon

Jaded Dawn at Allstar's

Roxi D'Lite in Wisconsin

Starfall at Hustler LV

Joslyn James Birthday Event

Jacky Joy Dance Scheduled

Tanya Tate Speaks at University

Adrianna Luna at Pink Pony

Gia Steel Karaoke XXX

Cyrus & De Leon Birthday Party

Sommers Headlines Penthouse Club

Nikki Benz Canadian Appearances

Monroe Valentino Karaoke XXX

Britney Shannon in Atlantic City

Kayla-Jane Danger Karaoke XXX

Vicki Chase Headlines Expo

Foxxx & Johnson Party

LATATA AEE Party

Clubs & Appearances Section Index

     
Copyright © 1998 - 2014 Adult Industry News (AINews.com)
All materials constituting text, articles, press releases, stories, columns, photographs, graphics, and code on the AINews.com domain are protected by copyright, and either owned by Adult Industry News (AINews.com), or reproduced with permission from other copyright owners. It may be downloaded and printed for personal reference, but not otherwise copied, altered in any way, or transmitted to others, without the written permission of Adult Industry News (AINews.com).