Quick Index
 Adult Industry News
Search AINews Database
Type Keyword or Phrase Here
EXPO 2015, August 23-26, New Orleans

Front Page
Film News
Media News
Business News
Clubs & Appearances
Law & Politics
Internet & Mobile News
Lifestyles Arts Health Charity
Letters to the Editor
Movie Spotlight Reviews
Pornstar Pages
AINews Staff
Ad Rates
PR 101: Press Release Service

Caliente Nudist Vacations!

Join Tera Patrick

July 13, 2001 10:35am
Questions Raised About Obscenity Laws
Source: AP
by: Liz Sidoti

(COLUMBUS, OH) -- First Amendment experts are alarmed by the case of an Ohio man who got 10 years in prison for child pornography for scribbling made-up tales in his private journal about molesting children.

Lawyers specializing in free-speech cases and obscenity law believe Brian Dalton's case is the first anywhere in the United States in which someone was successfully prosecuted for child porn that involved writings, not images.

They are also disturbed that the case involved porn that was for Dalton's private use and was not disseminated.

``His thoughts may be disturbing and repugnant, but he has got a right to have them and write them down for his own use,'' said Raymond Vasvari, legal director for the Ohio chapter of the American Civil Liberties Union (news - web sites).

Dalton's case has raised so many questions that he is considering trying to withdraw his guilty plea, defense attorney Isabella Dixon said Thursday.

Ron O'Brien, the Franklin County prosecutor who has hailed the case as a breakthrough in child-pornography prosecution, declined comment.

Dalton, 22, pleaded guilty last week to pandering obscenity involving a minor. As part of the plea bargain, a second count was dropped for five fewer years in prison.

Dalton, who was on probation from a 1998 pandering conviction involving pornographic photographs of children, was charged after his probation officer found the journal during a routine search of his home.

The 14-page journal contained stories about three children - ages 10 and 11 - being caged in a basement, molested and tortured. The contents were so disturbing that members of a grand jury asked a detective to stop reading after about two pages, a prosecutor said. Prosecutors said the stories are pure fiction.

Dalton was charged under Ohio's 1989 child porn law, which bans possession of obscene material involving children. He was not charged under Ohio's obscenity law, which requires dissemination and not just possession.

Ohio's law is broad in describing child pornography as ``material'' and not simply ``images,'' as in most other states, said Bruce Taylor, president of the National Law Center for Children and Families, which helps prosecutors in child porn cases.

Dalton's lawyer said her client ``felt it was in his best interest'' to plead guilty. She would not say what she advised him to do.

Dalton cannot challenge the constitutionality of the law unless he petitions the court to let him change his plea.

Some lawyers specializing in First Amendment cases said they believe he would win in court.

Robert O'Neil, director of the Thomas Jefferson Center for the Protection of Free Expression at the University of Virginia, said the case is ``astounding'' because it goes against U.S. Supreme Court (news - web sites) rulings.

The high court has held that child pornography is limited to images. The court is set to hear arguments in a California case this fall about whether purely computer-generated images of children engaged in sex - not images of actual children - constitute child pornography.

The Supreme Court also has ruled that obscene material is illegal only if it is disseminated and not simply possessed, but that the mere possession of child porn can be prosecuted if there is an overriding societal interest in protecting children.

``Here, that whole rationale doesn't apply,'' said David Goldberger, an Ohio State University law professor who specializes in First Amendment issues. ``There's no indication that any children were harmed in its production or that children would be harmed.''

Janet LaRue, senior director of legal studies at the Washington-based Family Research Council, which fights child pornography, said Dalton's tales could be extremely dangerous because they could entice him to seduce children.

``It's like an arsonist with matches,'' LaRue said. ``But while we admire a prosecutor who is concerned about the potential of children being harmed, we recognize that this case has serious problems.''

Gary Daniels, spokesman of the New York-based National Coalition Against Censorship, said: ``It's one thing to get an obscenity prosecution when there's visual images. To suggest that something could be obscene in a written form points out the contradictions in obscenity law.''

``If you're going to use this kind of logic in prosecuting people,'' he said, ``that means that any person who writes something in a fictional manner about breaking the law could be breaking the law.''

Casey Cumz 03

See BiBi Jones at Digital Playground

Top Stories

Modern Comstockery

Nikki Phoenix Appearance

Rock’N’SeXXXy Welcomes Billy Blair

Karaoke XXX Needs New Location

Jane & Ward Hosting XRCO

SashaBrabuster's XXX Comeback

Control ~ Reviewer Rated

XRCO 2015 Nominees

A Leaner Message

MWA: 02/26/15

50 Shades of Grey ~ Cinema Seen

XRCO 2015 Hall of Fame

Interview with Ela Darling

Derrick Pierce Interview

The News Rack: Naked Swingers

MWA: 02/07/15

Interview of Holly Heart

ED Expo to Big Easy

Hof on Phoenix Hooker Bust

I Know You

Cal/OSHA vs Evil Angel

Layla Price at Foxxx Booth

Star.XXX Blasts Off

Puma Swede on Jukeboxx Live

MWA: 01/11/15

MWA: 01/19/15

Nikki Phoenix Party

Viva Las Vicki

Freedom Acres Open House

Kendra Lust in Detroit

MWA: 01/10/15

MWA: 01/03/15

Starr Sisters in Houston

MWA: 01/02/15

MWA: 01/01/15

Nikki Phoenix Update

MWA: 10th Anniversary Column

MWA: 12/30/14

Vegas Heat Party

MWA: 12/27/14

XBIZ Rooftop Party

MWA: 12/26/14

Welcome 2015!

Canadian Foot Porn

Actress as an Artist

MWA: 12/14/14

Pushed Into the Corner

Tod Hunter Press Releases

Global Adult Industry Association

Pornography Feminism

Merry XXXmas, Happy Xanukkah

Rock'N'Sexxxy 12/10/2014

MWA: 12/05/14

Karlie Montana Interview

Deep Vision ThunderRama

Hackin Jack vs Chainsaw Chick

BBW Eliza Allure Interview

MWA: 11/20/14

Tara Lynn Foxx Retires

Treacherous ~ Reviewer Rated

Bright Lights, Lonely Nights

Taormino Speaks at Goucher

Cumisha Amado at Sagebrush

Vivid Radio 1st Anniversary

The Gardener ~ Reviewer Rated

BoodiGo: Privacy & Porn

Shades of Scarlet ~ Reviewer Rated

AINews: Skow Among Best

Heaven & Hell Halloween Party

These Things We Do ~ Reviewer Rated

Farrah Abraham at Hustler Hollywood

Sex Workshop Hustler San Diego

Halloween Art Show

O Awards Pre-Noms Open

Trophy Girl Casting Call

Cum in Me Baby 4 ~ Reviewer Rated

More Phoenix Mainstream

BoodiGo Partners PornGuardian

BoodiGo Supports ASACP

BoodiGo Blocks Child Porn

Boodigo Adult Search Engine

AVN Show Discounts End Today

Inside The Industry 10/08/2014

Amber Lynn at Wasteland

Nikki's Fit as Phoenix

Vivid Extends Patrick Hosting

Fake Test Results

Angelyne on Amber Lynn's RNSU

Red Cardinal Wraps Betrothed

Siri Wins Round 2

J.Lo Doc Johnson Offer

Stripclub Microbrewery on CNN

Father's Day ~ Reviewer Rated

Our Father ~ Reviewer Rated

Nikki Phoenix Album Released

Passport to Hustler Event

Fox News Wasteland

Asianmodelpalooza 14

Nikki Phoenix Appearances

Nikki Phoenix Karaoke XXX

Nina Elle Retains Star Factory

Tasha Reign Grads UCLA

Tera Patrick Hosts Vivid Radio

It's Just Work

Traci Bryant Goes Legal

CET Free Panel Month

Miss LA Karaoke XXX

Freedom Acres Location

Summer Lovers

Nikki Delano at Centerfolds

Karen Summer Returns

Advertise on AINews

Cytherea Auctions Fan Scene

Entertainment is Entertainment is Entertainment

Stories From

Law & Politics

Modern Comstockery

Hof on Phoenix Hooker Bust

Cal/OSHA vs Evil Angel

Pornstar Graduates Law School

AHF Against AB 999

CraigsErotica Letter to Senators

Amazon Crushes Small Business

Letter of Equality

ASACP Service Recognition Award

Suit Filed Challenging Measure B

ASACP Ready For Internext

Octomom Loses Civil Suit


Crakmedia ASACP Corporate Sponsor

Mo Reese Statement

CAM4 Newest ASACP Sponsor

Mo Reese FSC Nom

Amber Lynn Seeks FSC Board

Suit Against Measure B

Law Puts Con in Condom

No on B: Here's Why

NO on B Campaign

NO on B Bus Tour

GFY: Vote No on B

Margold on Erection Election

Alex Chance in Documentary

Yahshua: No On B

No On 35 Rally

Why No On B

Measure B Threatens Freedom

Measure B Protest Video

No On B Raffle

Alia Janine: No On B

AHF Vilifies Porn

No on B Event

Alia Janine Against Measure B

Fight Measure B

Takedown Piracy Removes 10,000,000

John Stagliano Keynotes CatalystCon

Hirsch Blasts Trueman

Hirsch Cautions GOP

LATATA Files Injunction

Child Porn Hotline Increased

Vette Scores on AFF

Nicole Houde Assault Arrest

YouJizz Sued

Dickinson Defends Travolta

Kardashian/Humphries Divorce Deposition

Three Stooges Porn Controversy

Suing: Wasn't Sexy Enough

Lords of Acid Censored

Nate Glass on CNBC

Law & Politics Section Index

Copyright © 1998 - 2015 Adult Industry News (AINews.com)
All materials constituting text, articles, press releases, stories, columns, photographs, graphics, and code on the AINews.com domain are protected by copyright, and either owned by Adult Industry News (AINews.com), or reproduced with permission from other copyright owners. It may be downloaded and printed for personal reference, but not otherwise copied, altered in any way, or transmitted to others, without the written permission of Adult Industry News (AINews.com).